dsh-skill-switch

dsh-skill-switch

A DeepSeek Harness plugin about spending fewer tokens on skills you are not using — by session, and by whole family.

Every session gets a collapsible strip above the composer showing which skills it loads, with a toggle per skill and three posture presets. Large interdependent skill families can be parked outside the host's skill hub entirely and mounted as one unit.

---

The problem: skills cost tokens even when unused

DSH skills are already lazily loaded — the model only reads a SKILL.md body when it calls the skill tool. The catalog is not lazy. Before every step, the official tool-skill injects every model-invocable skill as an <available_skills> block, so a skill you never touch still bills you on every single step. And there is no way to say "this session is just a conversation — do not offer me any of these" before it starts.

Three layers, and which one actually matters

The design targets three separate costs, in ascending order of size:

Layer 2 is the point. A catalog line is tens to ~200 tokens; a real load injects a body that is routinely hundreds to thousands. Layer 1 exists mainly to achieve layer 2 — hiding the line is how the model stops knowing the skill is there. Layer 3 is the smallest but free once you are already all-off.

Measured on a real repository

Numbers below come from an actual ~/.agents/skills hub and a parked family. They are characters, not tokens — token count depends on the tokenizer and on how the model splits mixed CJK/Latin text, so the honest unit here is the one that can be reproduced from the files. Treat the ratios as the finding, not the absolute figures:

Two things that table says:

• Catalog lines are not small. 205 characters per line is typical for a well-written skill description — that is the price of good routing, and it is paid every step.
• Parking beats hiding. Mounting that family costs 5,559 characters whether or not the session uses it. Parked, it costs nothing, because the directories are genuinely moved out of the hub. Hiding skills in the catalog still pays for their lines — the registry must discover them before anything can filter them.

Why per-session, and why per-family

Two design choices follow from how skills are actually used:

• Per session, because intent changes by conversation. A pure brainstorming session should not pay for the coding toolkit, and a "no skills at all" posture should be one click rather than an argument with the model.
• Per family, because some families cannot be split. Their members link each other by relative path (lark-doc → ../lark-shared), so loading one alone breaks its references, while listing all of them bills every line. All-or-nothing is not a simplification — it is the only shape that matches the dependency.

---

Install

# 1. Build (inside the plugin directory)
npm install && npm run build

# 2. Link it into a profile: add to <profile>/package.json
#    dependencies: { "dsh-skill-switch": "link:/path/to/dsh-skill-switch" }
#    dsh.profile.bundles: [..., "dsh-skill-switch"]

# 3. Let the plugin resolve @deepseek-ai/* from the profile
ln -s ~/.dsh/profiles/node_modules <plugin>/node_modules

Or, once published:

dsh plugin --profile web add dsh-skill-switch

Restart DSH afterwards.

⚠️ This plugin replaces the official skill tool. Its cordis.patch.yml disables @deepseek-ai/dsh-tool-skill and registers its own skill tool plus session catalog. The replacement is a port of the official implementation with per-session filtering added — not a wrapper around it. If you depend on the official plugin's exact behaviour, read Why it takes over tool-skill before installing.

---

Configuration

Defaults are neutral and live in the bundled cordis.patch.yml. Everything deployment-specific belongs in your profile patch (<profile>/cordis.patch.yml), keyed by the row id:

- id: skill-switch
  name: dsh-skill-switch
  config:
    defaultMode: all          # posture a new session starts in: all | none | work
    workSkills: []            # skills the `work` posture enables
    syncScript: ''            # absolute path of a sync script; empty hides the control
    hubDir: ''                # absolute path of the hub the host scans (needed for skillGroups)
    skillGroups: []           # all-or-nothing bundles, see below

defaultMode: all keeps the stock behaviour — you turn things off when you want to. Set none if you would rather opt in per session.

Sync (syncScript)

The host reads skills from a hub directory, not from wherever you author them. If your skill repository lives elsewhere (a network mount, a synced folder), a script bridges the two:

Point syncScript at your script and a Sync skills button appears. Clicking it runs the script, invalidates the catalog cache, and pushes a refresh to every open strip.

Manual on purpose. If the repository is on a network mount, every scan costs something; you decide when to pay it, and nothing runs while you are not looking. Both halves are required — without the sync the host does not know the new skill exists, so there is nothing for the strip to refresh.

Feedback follows the macOS idiom rather than a persistent log pane:

Success needs no acknowledgement, so it withdraws. Failure stays because it asks something of you, and its text is what tells you what went wrong.

Skill groups (skillGroups)

Some skill families are both huge and interdependent: a member's SKILL.md links its siblings by relative path (lark-doc → ../lark-shared). A per-skill switch cannot express them — loading one alone breaks its references, and listing all of them costs their catalog lines whether or not the session uses them.

A skill group parks the family outside the hub and moves it in or out as one unit:

hubDir: '/home/you/.agents/skills'
skillGroups:
  - id: lark
    label: 'Feishu CLI'
    description: '27 Feishu skills, mounted and parked as one unit'
    parkDir: '/home/you/.agents-parked/lark'
    discover: true          # read members from parkDir; no hand-maintained list

The strip shows a dashed chip per group: ⬡ Feishu CLI 27 when parked, solid when mounted. Clicking moves the whole family.

Why whole groups, and why moving directories rather than hiding lines. Three design decisions, each buying tokens:

1. Parked costs 0, hidden costs its lines. The cheapest token is one never sent. Hiding a skill in the catalog still requires the registry to discover it first, and discovery is what renders the line — so per-skill filtering can only ever remove the line it already paid to compute. Moving the directory out of the hub means the registry never sees it at all. On the measured family above that is the difference between 0 and 5,559 characters.
2. All-or-nothing, because the family is genuinely atomic. Members reference each other by relative path; a per-member switch would let you build a broken state (one member mounted, its lark-shared dependency parked). A group switch cannot express that state, which is the point.
3. A roster file, so the count survives a restart. After mounting, the park directory is empty — membership has to be recorded somewhere, and an in-memory list would report 0 members on the next host start, which is exactly the state the user just switched into.

Member roster. Mounting writes the member names to <parkDir>/.members. After a mount the park directory is empty, so that file is the only record of membership — an in-memory list would not survive a host restart. Unmounting reads it to decide what moves back.

Safety boundary. Group membership is read from parkDir only, never by scanning the hub root — the hub holds unrelated skills, and scanning it would adopt them into the group and sweep them into the park directory on the next unmount. test/group.test.mjs locks this down.

---

Interface

A collapsible strip above the composer.

Collapsed (the default — one line):

▶ Skills  3/9  jxh, video-diag, insight-mining        Sync skills

Expanded:

▼ Skills  3/9                                          Sync skills
[Chat] [Work] [All]  ⬡ Feishu CLI 27  ● jxh  ○ video-diag

• Click ▶ Skills to collapse or expand; the choice is remembered in localStorage
• Collapsed, it lists the enabled skill names, so you can confirm at a glance
• Solid dot = loaded, hollow = not; click to toggle
• Chat = none, Work = only workSkills, All = everything
• Groups render as dashed chips with their member count

Collapsed by default because this seat sits directly above the composer: an expanded chip list pushes the conversation up.

---

State semantics

In-memory, per session. A new session starts from defaultMode, and a restart forgets every toggle. That is deliberate — each session picks again, with no storage dependency.

Skill groups are the exception: they move directories on disk, so their state is a property of the machine, not the session, and it persists.

---

Architecture

┌─ Browser ────────────────────────────────┐
│ conversation.input.dock: the strip        │
│         │ fetch /skill-switch/*           │
└─────────┼─────────────────────────────────┘
┌─ Host ───────────────────────────────────┐
│ webServer routes + Map<sessionId, state>  │
│ agent/created → register tool + catalog   │
│ renders the catalog itself (filtered)     │
└───────────────────────────────────────────┘

Why it takes over tool-skill

Two constraints rule out a lighter interception:

1. ctx.skills.registerProvider() always files into the GLOBAL layer, and its list() receives only { cwd, signal } — no agent identity — so a provider cannot branch per session.
2. The official catalog compares digests. Filtering behind its back makes it see a changed catalog and publish a replacement message on every step, polluting the session log.

So this plugin owns the catalog injection and the skill tool, registering them on agent.ctx. tools.register reads the caller's scope, so the registration is per-session and is collected when the agent is disposed.

Why disabling everything unmounts the tool instead of using tools.restrict(): a restriction filters only what a scope inherits and never what its own layer registers. The skill tool is registered in the agent's own layer, so a restriction cannot remove it and its schema would stay in the prompt — layer 3 of the token model above would be unreachable. Unmounting the registration is what actually takes the schema out of the prompt.

Why the takeover is worth its maintenance cost. The alternative — leaving the official plugin in place and filtering behind it — cannot work, for the digest reason above: every step would append a catalog-update message, so the "saving" would cost more context than it recovered. Owning the injection is the price of the per-session switch existing at all.

Cost: upstream changes to dsh-tool-skill are not picked up automatically. The logic here is a port of the official implementation and behaves identically.

---

Version compatibility

DSH validates a third-party bundle's peer ranges and silently skips the whole bundle when they do not match — the plugin does not load, but its patch still applies. Two things bite:

1. The runtime version is not the version in the profile. The desktop app redirects @deepseek-ai/* to the packages inside its own asar (0.2.0-rc.2 today) via the loader's internal.import(specifier, bareModuleBaseUrl), not to <profile>/node_modules. Writing a peer range from the profile's copies can therefore fail validation.
2. The version on npm is not the version the runtime provides either. The check compares each range against the runtime version, so a package that stopped publishing to npm at 0.1.x while the runtime ships 0.2.x still has to be ranged against 0.2.x. Ranging it against what npm happens to offer rejects the bundle. This is the mistake that shipped in 5b85d5d: dsh-client-runtime publishes only up to 0.1.1-rc.2 on npm, but the desktop runtime provides 0.2.0-rc.2, so a ^0.1.x range skipped the whole plugin.
3. A peer range without an explicit prerelease branch silently excludes every prerelease build. Use a union that names the prerelease tuple:

"@deepseek-ai/dsh-skill": "^0.1.0-rc.2 || ^0.1.0-rc.6 || ^0.1.5-rc.1 || ^0.2.0-rc.1 || ^0.2.0-rc.2"

Diagnosing: plugin_manager list_bundles — look for error.code: "incompatible-version" on the bundle. The failure is silent from the plugin's side: it does not load, yet its cordis.patch.yml still applies, so tool-skill stays disabled while nothing takes over the skill tool.

Verifying a range before shipping: check it against the runtime version with the same library DSH uses, rather than by reading version lists.

const semver = require('semver')
semver.satisfies('0.2.0-rc.2', range, { includePrerelease: true })

Cross-version API differences

0.2.0-rc.2 changed Session from a whole-log array to seq + eventAt() (the old reads are deprecated), and agent/pre-step decisions are best spread rather than rebuilt. catalog.ts's readEventsBackwards() accepts both shapes, so one build runs on either runtime.

---

Tests

bash test/run-all.sh

---

Known limitations

• Takes over the official skill tool. Upstream changes to dsh-tool-skill need manual follow-up.
• Skill discovery is not this plugin's job. The web composition disables the host skill-filesystem row ("presets own local discovery"); a deployment that wants a local repository re-enables that provider against its own hub. This plugin only filters what the registry already knows about.
• Group membership by discovery reads parkDir only. A family mounted and then deleted from the hub by hand loses its roster on the next restart.
• Session state is in-memory; only group state is durable.

---

License

MIT